Cottage 2, The Captain's House exterior, blue-gray cottage with covered porch, deck, and flowering shrubs

Cottage 2

The Captain's House

4Bedrooms
2.5Bathrooms
A/CCentral air

Fully renovated in 2025 and set right on the water, Cottage 2 is the crown jewel of the property. Wide-plank floors and whitewashed knotty pine carry a mid-century modern sensibility throughout, dressed in whites, beiges, and creams with complementing natural textures. Sliding glass doors run the width of the living room, making the bay view visible from the entire open-concept living space. It's sophisticated, serene, and a guest favorite.

Sunset over Peconic Bay as seen from Cottage 2

The View

From this perch right on the water, you can watch the weather roll in, the sun go down, or the light glistening on the water as the boats go by all day long. With outdoor lounge and dining seating for eight, a beverage refrigerator, and a propane grill, the deck extends the cottage's living space, allowing guests to take full advantage of the stunning view and the sea breeze.

Living room at Cottage 2 with an electric fireplace, oversized chaise, and sliding glass doors open to the bay

Living, Right on the Water

An oversized chaise is the best seat in the house — for reading, for relaxing, or simply for taking in the view. An electric fireplace keeps things cozy when the evenings turn cool, and the water is never out of sight.

Open-concept kitchen, dining, and living space at Cottage 2 with a skylight and glass dining table

Kitchen & Dining

A skylight floods the kitchen with natural light, setting the tone for a space that feels open, polished, and beautifully composed. The glass-topped dining table keeps the room visually light, while a custom rolling island and wine-glass console add tailored function for entertaining. Together, the details create a seamless flow between kitchen and dining, with every piece chosen to enhance both the beauty and the use of the space.

Primary bedroom at Cottage 2 with whitewashed wood walls and local map art Bedroom at Cottage 2 with a high-riser bed and playful East End whale-themed details.

Four Bedrooms

The spacious primary suite features a king bed, a reading nook, a full en-suite bath, and a walk-in closet. The second king room is similarly generous and is anchored by a family heirloom mid-century modern highboy. A queen bedroom with its own half-bath and exceptional water views is a coastal retreat in and of itself. The petite fourth bedroom brings a touch of playful East End character, while a high-riser bed gives the room the versatility to serve as a cozy den or comfortable sleeping quarters for one or two guests of any age.

The Yard

Seafaring details are woven quietly through the grounds of The Captain's House, from nautical lighting to weathered timber pilings. For those who enjoy fishing or harvesting seafood, the bay offers the pleasure of bringing the day's catch straight to the table. Oregano, lemon thyme, and mint return to the cottage's herb garden each year, and guests are welcome to plant their own favorites, as well, to inspire and complement meals grilled on the deck or finished in the kitchen. For the home chef, having such freshness at hand is one of the quiet luxuries of elegant East End summer living.

The lawn at Cottage 2 with a flowering pink crepe myrtle in evening light and the bay beyond

Floor Plan

Floor plan of Cottage 2, The Captain's House

Click or tap the floor plan to view it full size.

Sleeping Arrangements

Waterfront Setting

All six cottages are located on the same Peconic Bay waterfront property, extending from the road to the private beach.

Direct water views from this cottage

Amenities

Rates & Availability

Fourteen-night stays currently range from approximately $4,000 in the off-season to $14,000 during peak summer. Rates vary by dates and are subject to change.

Full Listing & Availability

The photographs shown here are a curated selection. For the complete photo collection, current availability, pricing, and official rental information, please contact Peconic View Cottages.

Request Full Listing & Availability

See the other cottages

Back to The Cottages